What distinction does the textbook make between a disability and a handicap what example is given?

What distinction does the textbook make between a disability and a handicap what example is given?

We often use these words interchangeably. Similarly, there are common associations with these words, such as the terms visual impairment, learning disability, and physical handicap.

But if we switch the terms, for example, saying learning impairment, physical disability, and visual handicap, instead; or physical impairment, visual disability, and learning handicap, do we alter their meanings, or do they basically mean the same?

Are you confused yet?

One way to help us understand the different aspects in the area of special needs is by clarifying terms. This also helps us in untangling confusions, correcting misconceptions and busting myths.

We develop a better grasp of the roles of treatment, intervention, and environmental modifications in helping and assisting individuals with special needs the moment we distinguish these different terms from one another.

The often cited definitions of these terms are provided by the World Health Organization (1980) in The International Classification of Impairments, Disabilities, and Handicaps. Impairment is defined as “any loss or abnormality of psychological, physiological or anatomical structure or function.” Disability, on the other hand, means “any restriction or lack (resulting from an impairment) of ability to perform an activity in the manner or within the range considered normal for a human being.” Lastly, handicap is defined as “a disadvantage for a given individual that limits or prevents the fulfillment of a role that is normal.”

When we unpack these definitions based on their traditional use, impairment means that there is a problem with an organ or structure of the body. It is focused on the actual malformation or malfunction in the body. When we say disability, it means that a person has a functional limitation due to his or her impairment. When we say handicap, it means that the person experiences a disadvantage in filling a normal role in life compared to his or her peers due to the functional limitation caused by the impairment.

Are you still confused?

Let’s use the terms above to explain the differences:

  • Physical impairment pertains to a loss of an anatomical structure; for the benefit of this exercise, let’s say the person lost a leg due to an accident. He can wear prosthetics as a replacement of the lost leg.
  • Physical disability now refers to the inability to walk. To be able to navigate the surroundings, the person can use a wheelchair.
  • Physical handicap now means that this person faces disadvantages that prevent him or her to perform a normal role in life, such as not being able to climb stairs anymore. Or run a marathon. Or be a basketball player. Here is where the environment plays a part. By providing wheelchair access or lift for the person with physical disability, he or she will have no problem going up to the next floors of a building. By providing multi-sport events for athletes with physical disabilities, such as Paralympics, the person will still able to participate in sports.

Let’s try another one:

  • Dyslexia is an example of learning impairment, a reading impairment in particular. Let’s say the student has an above-average intelligence as well as good vision and hearing. Therefore, the impairment is the brain’s inability to decode words to be able to read. The brain cannot correctly associate the sounds with the letter symbols.
  • The inability to read is now the student’s learning disability. It can be improved by employing specific intervention programmes such as multi-sensory instruction in teaching reading.
  • The person may experience various learning handicaps in school, and he or she may fail in class. For example, the student may not be able to complete the reading requirements in class. However, if certain adjustments are provided for the learner, such as taping lectures and listening to books on audiotapes, then he or she may fare well, similar to his or her peers. This will decrease the student’s handicap and will not interfere with his or her progress in school.

It is very important to know that we have a vital role in helping individuals with special needs. By adapting and modifying the environment to be able to assist and accommodate them, their disability does not have to be a handicap. Remember, a handicap is a disadvantage, and oftentimes, it is the environment that causes the disadvantage. When we do our part to meet their needs, they are able to fulfil a role similar to their peers.

It is possible that a disability is the cause of a handicap. For example, if a person has a disability that prevents them from being able to move their legs, it may result in a handicap in driving.

Disabled people do not have to be handicapped, especially if they can find a way around their disability. For example, braille for the visually impaired or wheel chairs for those who cannot walk.

Comparison chart

Disability versus Handicap comparison chart
What distinction does the textbook make between a disability and a handicap what example is given?
DisabilityHandicap
Introduction (from Wikipedia)Disability is the consequence of an impairment that may be physical, cognitive, mental, sensory, emotional, developmental, or some combination of these. A disability may be present from birth, or occur during a person's lifetime. any physical or mental defect, congenital or acquired, preventing or restricting a person from participating in normal life or limiting their capacity to work.

Definitions

A disability is an inability to execute some class of movements, or pick up sensory information of some sort, or perform some cognitive function, that typical unimpaired humans are able to execute or pick up or perform. A disability may be physical, cognitive, mental, sensory, emotional, developmental or some combination of these.

A handicap is an inability to accomplish something one might want to do, that most others around one are able to accomplish. For example, reading, walking, catching a ball, or communicating.

The Relationship Between Disability and Handicap

The view of disability as a social construct holds that society assumes that everyone is a fully functioning, able-bodied person, which prevents the disabled from fully functioning in society, thereby creating disability.

When systems are designed thoughtfully to accommodate the needs, challenges and varying degrees of ability of different people in society, people with disabilities can fully participate in (or use) these systems. One of the major goals of the disability rights movement is to raise awareness of how systems can (and should) be designed to serve all people, not just the majority of people who happen to have no significant impairments.

For example, buildings and sidewalks that are designed to be wheelchair-accessible eliminate any handicap for people with physical disabilities (whether permanent or temporary). Closed captioning on TV lets people with hearing impairments to enjoy video programming.

Sensory, Intellectual or other Neurological Differences

While physical disabilities are easy to identify and appreciate, mental disabilities require the same level of thought when designing systems. Examples include sensory processing challenges that make it hard for some people to stay in very noisy environments or areas with flashing or fluorescent lights. Some kids may have attention, communication or cognitive challenges that can be mitigated by providing extra time for taking their tests. These are all examples of ways in which systems can be designed to let people overcome their disability so it does not become a handicap.

What is politically correct to say?

It is politically correct to say that a person has a disability and it's impolite to call someone handicapped.


References

  • handicap - Wiktionary.org
  • disability - Wiktionary.org
  • Blindness No Obstacle To Those With Sharp Ears - NPR

  • Follow
  • Share
  • Cite
  • Authors

Share this comparison:

If you read this far, you should follow us:

"Handicapped vs Disabled." Diffen.com. Diffen LLC, n.d. Web. 24 Sep 2022. < >

What are the main components of most definitions of learning disabilities?

Learning disabilities may manifest as difficulty: (1) processing information by visual and auditory, means, which may impact upon reading, spelling, writing, and understanding or using language, (2) prioritizing, organizing, doing mathematics, and following instructions, (3) storing or retrieving information from short ...

What type of approach to understanding language seems best for students who are hard of hearing?

Using Interpreters An interpreter is someone who facilitates communication and conveys all auditory and signed information so that both hearing and deaf individuals may fully interact. There are many types of interpreters, including American Sign Language (ASL), oral, tactile, and cued speech.

Which one of the following situation is considered a language difference rather than a language disorder?

41) Which one of the following situations is considered a language difference rather than a language disorder? Explanation: D) Language differences primarily represent variations due to experiences in a particular society or culture and are not necessarily a disorder. An example would be speaking in a strong dialect.

What type of intervention appears to be the most successful in helping students with attention and learning deficits?

Direct instruction appears the most effective approach for improving word recognition skills in students with learning disabilities.