In the course of designing a research project, researchers may find it useful to include a debriefing of the study for participants at the close of the project. The debriefing process is a requirement for studies that employ deception (#1 below), however it could also be used as an educational tool (#2 below). What follows are: a) guidelines for preparing a Kuali Protocol submission that incorporates deception and/or requires a debriefing process, and b) specific issues that should be addressed in the debriefing form. Show
1. Use of Debriefing for Deception StudiesResearchers may find that the use of deception, or incomplete disclosure, is a necessary tool for their study. However, the use of such techniques raises special issues that the IRB will review closely. Deception occurs when participants are deliberately given false information about some aspect of the research. Incomplete disclosure occurs when participants are not given information about the real purpose or the nature of the research. Preparing Your Kuali Protocol Submission for Deception Studies.A. Justifying the Use of DeceptionAn investigator proposing to use deception or incomplete disclosure should justify its use in their IRB protocol submission. Studies utilizing deception should not be submitted for Exempt Review, rather, depending on the nature of the deception the study will be reviewed under either Expedited or Full Board Review processes. Please address the following when preparing your IRB protocol submission:
B. Debriefing Requirements and ProcessThe debriefing is an essential part of the consent process and is mandatory when the research study involves deception. The debriefing provides participants with a full explanation of the hypothesis being tested, procedures to deceive participants and the reason(s) why it was necessary to deceive them. It should also include other relevant background information pertaining to the study. After participants have been debriefed immediately following completion of the study the IRB expects that participants will be given a debriefing statement to take with them. For online studies the debriefing process should occur as soon as a participant has completed the research activity. As an added measure, it may be necessary to send an email out to all participants after the study is completed to ensure that all participants (those that completed and those that may have stopped mid-way) receive a debriefing form. The debriefing statement must be reviewed and approved by the IRB. The process to debrief participants must be explained in your IRB submission. Your submission must indicate who will debrief participants. The IRB expects that this person is a member of the research team who has knowledge about the research and the deception. The Debriefing Form should include the following:
The IRB has provided a deception research debriefing form template for researchers to use. Please note that the UMass Psychology Department may have their own guidelines and specifications regarding debriefing forms used by researchers in the department. For further information on psychology department specific guidelines please see their website. 2. Use of Debriefing as an Educational ToolFinally, the IRB suggests that the debriefing also be used as an educational tool, even when the study does not involve the use of deception. Participants should be given a simple, clear and informative explanation of the rationale for the design of the study and the methods used. It should also ask for and answer participant’s questions. The IRB has provided a generic debriefing form template for researchers to use as an educational tool Source material for this policy guidance was provided by the University of Connecticut IRB. The UMass IRB gratefully acknowledges this support. Which of the following is a rule that researchers must follow when using deception in their research?Deception in psychological research is often stated as acceptable only when all of the following conditions are met: 1) no other nondeceptive method exists to study the phenomenon of interest; 2) the study makes significant contributions to scientific knowledge; 3) the deception is not expected to cause significant ...
What is deception and debriefing?The debriefing is an essential part of the informed consent process and is mandatory when the research study involves use of deception. The debriefing provides participants with a full explanation of the hypothesis being tested, procedures to deceive participants and the reason(s) why it was necessary to deceive them.
What process should occur after using deception in research?Debriefing Requirements
Researchers must debrief subjects (or their legally authorized representatives) about the use of deception whenever feasible. Generally, subjects should be debriefed immediately following their participation.
What is one of the arguments against using deception in research quizlet?Which of the following is one of the arguments against the use of deception in psychological research? Deception causes people to believe psychologists are "tricksters" or liars.
|